Symposium: Prostituted women
and their clients: New Canadian research data
Moderator: M. Alexis Kennedy
The world of prostitution is receiving
new attention in Canada as we come to grips with the most serious serial murder case in our countrys history. Prostitution has traditionally been considered a victimless crime but a new awareness is beginning to emerge
of the traumas faced daily by street prostitutes. This symposium will present
findings from recent research projects conducted in Toronto and Vancouver on both prostituted women and the men who exploit
them. The anonymity of men who solicit prostitutes, johns, has hindered research on this population of offenders to date.
Three talks will unveil Canadian johns and a final talk will discuss the victimization of prostituted women.
Talk 1: Johns
in Toronto: Information from the Evaluation of the Toronto John School
Scot Wortley & Benedikt Fischer, Centre of Criminology, University of Toronto
This talk
will discuss the results of a longitudinal survey conducted with men who participated in Torontos diversion program for people
arrested for soliciting or attempting to solicit a prostitute. 366 men were interviewed
both before and after attending the John School. The demographics of the participants
will be discussed in relation to the demographics of the Toronto area. Attitude
change will be examined longitudinally. History of experience with prostitution,
in addition to self-disclosed reasons for using prostitution will be reported. Participants
feelings about being arrested and the factors that made them chose to participate in the diversion program will be discussed. The long-term impact of John school attendance will compare changes in attitudes toward
prostitution six months after attending the program to pre-attendance and immediately post-attendance attitudes.
Talk 2: Johns
in Vancouver: Demographics, experience and attitudes
M. Alexis Kennedy, Boris B. Gorzalka
& John C. Yuille, Department of Psychology, University of British Columbia
Research on the consumers of sex-trade
services or johns is relatively sparse compared to research on other sexual offenders.
Due to the underground nature of the sex-trade, finding consumers to survey can be difficult at times. From a theoretical
perspective, the client or purchaser is central to the crime of soliciting a prostitute. From a forensic psychology point
of view, the purchaser is a criminal element that we have very little psychological or social data on. From a social policy perspective, the purchaser is an identifiable target or point for social intervention. For any intervention to be successful, information on attitudes held by sex trade
consumers toward prostitution is essential.
This talk will explore the demographics
and attitudes of over 350 men arrested for trying to solicit sex from prostituted women and who chose to participate the Prostitution
Offender Program (POP). The POP is a daylong criminal justice diversion program offered in British Columbia. The demographic profile of these participants will include information on their ethnicity, age, educational
level, employment, marital status and health. Some information will be presented
on their experiences with prostitution, including frequency of use. The attitudes
that the participants hold towards the sexual exploitation of women and children living on the streets will also be explored.
Talk 3: Childhood
and occupational victimization of prostituted women in Vancouver
Jessica T. K. Bristowe, M. Alexis
Kennedy, Barry S. Cooper & John C. Yuille, Department of Psychology, University of British Columbia
Prostitution has been considered a "victimless crime" in which women are viewed as having chosen to sell their
bodies. However, prostituted women are constant victims of violent crimes such as rape, physical assault, and murder (Davis,
1993). Childhood sexual abuse has been identified as a risk factor for entering into the sex trade. This study will present
data on the rates of childhood and occupational victimization of women working on the streets in Vancouver, British Columbia.
Forty-two prostituted women were interviewed at a safe house in the downtown East Side of Vancouver. The women ranged in age
from 19 to 59 and reported their ethnic identity to be Caucasian or First Nations/Metis (50% each). Trained women interviewers
conducted confidential interviews and administered the questionnaires orally. Sexual abuse will be analyzed for familial versus
non-familial perpetrators. Other types of abuse experience will also be assessed such as rates of physical punishment, neglect,
negative home atmosphere and emotional abuse as measured by the Child Abuse and Trauma scale (Sanders & Becker-Lausen,
1995).
Talk 4: A Comparison
Study of the Sexual Attitudes and Behaviors in Men who Solicit Sex Versus Those Who Do Not
Carolin Klein, M. Alexis Kennedy,
Boris B. Gorzalka, & John C. Yuille
While several hypotheses have
been proposed for why men go to prostitutes (Jordan, 1997; Monto, 2000), to date there have been no empirical studies looking
at the differences in attitudes, behaviors, and sexual experiences of those who do and those who do not purchase sexual services.
As a result, there has been little evidence to either support or refute these theories.
Data presented here are the first part of a larger study looking at the variables often attributed to going to prostitutes
such as a higher than normal sex drive, dissatisfaction in, or lack of, intimate relationships, and an inability to get other
sexual partners. Over 250 university males who had never gone to prostitutes
filled out questionnaires identical to those filled out by 300 men arrested for communicating for the purposes of prostitution
who took part in the Prostitution Offender Program (POP). Data to be presented
will include comparisons between the two groups on dimensions such as sexual drive, sexual conservatism, and sexual satisfaction
as well as past sexual experiences. Gaining an understanding of the reasons behind
going to prostitutes is not only important from a behavioral and psychological perspective but may also have implications
for how the police and the court system deal with these offenders in the future.